Click Click Expose

March 17, 2008

HD DVD vs Blu Ray vs DVD – WTF!!

Okay – unless you have been on another planet, you have probably heard (even though you may not care) – that Blu Ray has won the high definition battle. Hooray some people say…hold the phone – others are saying.


Personally I think everyone loses in this war. Let’s forget about the fact that: 1) consumers were screaming bloody murder about having to choose a format, 2) that consumers are slowly (and I do mean slowly) adopting high definition in their homes, and 3) we can even forget the fact that prices are very high for high definition players and the movies. If we forget all of those things – there is one thing that matters – Sony gets to now dictate whatever price they want to get you to adopt the new format of choice.

Now, of course, I can’t blame them for this. After all if you go back in time, DVD players were outrageously high for several years before people could afford them. Fast forward to the present and Blu Ray & HD DVD prices were cut drastically after only one year!! GO FIGURE!! You can bet your bottom dollar that manufactures were not making much money on their hardware or software. So now, you better believe that the Blu Ray folks are going to raise prices little by little in an effort to recoup what they loss when they had to battle HD DVD. That’s why I think we all will lose in this format war that ended last month. I forsee that there will not be an affordable Blu Ray player coming out anytime this year (I mean like sub $200 affordable). That sucks…I love high definition and when a movie or tv show or documentary is filmed, edited and transferred in glorious 1080i or 1080p – the video is too die for….but I will be damn if I will pay $400 for a Blu Ray player and $40 for a Blu Ray movie…ain’t going to happen. And what most people forget is that most movies are not shot in true high def – but rather film that is transferred to high def (unless maybe they are shooting in 4K with the Red One but I digress).

So would I buy a Blu Ray player right now? NOPE. Do we even offer high definition as an option for our customers to buy? NOPE. Will I buy one in the future? Yeah maybe a year or 2 from now when they figure out what profile spec they want to use, 1080p TV prices drop a little more and Blu Ray players drop prices some more – then yeah – definitely will do it. Will we offer it to customers and begin filming in High Def? A year from now – yeah we will be forced too…

But for now, what will I do instead? I did what most people think is crazy. I bought a HD-DVD player, bought a bunch of HD DVD movies at ridiculously low prices to finish out my collection and can now watch movies in glorious 1080p at a price to die for. Sure after May, there will be no more new HD DVD movies – but my player will upconvert all my standard DVDs to near HD quality, I have some great movies on HD (there are over 450 in the western market alone & 800+ globally) and I can enjoy high def now without destroying my pocketbook for the next year or two. When I am done, I expect to have maybe 30 HD DVD titles (maybe more) and a player that would normally have cost me $1100 but instead only cost me around $500. Now to bad a deal!!!

It is just a shame that the only gay movie right now out on High Def (that I know) is Brokeback Mountain!!



  1. i was interested in hd movies but the longer the prices remain high the lower my interest is. there are other places that i could spend my fun money more wisely than a blu-ray player and some movies.

    Comment by dale — March 18, 2008 @ 12:37 pm | Reply

  2. I hear ya…during the format war, price kept me out of the equation. I couldn’t find myself justifying spending $30 on a movie when its counterpart in SD was between $15 and $20. But now, I find I can’t resist getting some of my favorite movies (and those I haven’t bought yet) in high def even if it is in a format that is no longer supported. The price now for HD DVD is (in my opinion) too good to pass up.

    Incidentally, on my next computer build in the next few months – I am going to invest in a blu ray/HD DVD optical drive – so I can still have my cake and eat it too. Play my low priced but high quality HD DVD movies and when a good sale on Blu Ray happens on a movie I like, I can still watch it on my HD computer monitor. For a computer geek like me, life is good!!!

    Comment by ccevideo — March 18, 2008 @ 9:58 pm | Reply

  3. Shades of Beta vs. VHS. And though I’d have no way of offering proof of the claim, those in the know contend that HD is superior to Bluray (as was Beta slightly superior to VHS). But when WB says it is releasing all ist future library in Bluray, well …

    Comment by Chris Holden — March 26, 2008 @ 4:20 pm | Reply

  4. Somehow i missed the point. Probably lost in translation 🙂 Anyway … nice blog to visit.

    cheers, Woodcutter.

    Comment by Woodcutter — June 19, 2008 @ 3:47 am | Reply

  5. 🙂 Woodcutter,

    The jist of the blog was to say that we have all as consumers lost out on the Blu Ray/HD DVD war. Unless you were a person that took advantage of the slash in prices when HD DVD ended last February – the cost is still too high for adoption by the mainstream public. People seem to like it and appreciate it for what it can do to change how you watch and enjoy movies – but the price to buy a Blu Ray player and blu Ray movies is so high, that it represents a barrier that a lot of people are not willing to overcome. I walked into Best Buy yesterday and saw a Blu Ray movie I would like to have but the price was $35.00 – that same movie on DVD is $17.99. An upconverting DVD player can be bought for $100 – a Blu Ray player can be bought for $400. Until Sony (et al) make it affordable – widespread adoption isn’t going to happen. The end of the High Def war should have done this – made prices affordable for everyone – the opposite has happen – prices still go up and adoption remains flat. It’s a shame really – watching a high def movie is so much better than standard definition.


    Comment by ccevideo — June 19, 2008 @ 10:27 am | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply to dale Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: